ORIGINAL 5
- Boston Pilgrims (2004-present) managed by Ryan Veno
- DC Dynasty (2004-present) managed by Eric Dunleavy
- also known as Houston Aces (2004)
- also known as Diamond Cutters (2006)
- Fenway Flats (2004-present) managed by Tim Cavanaugh
- Holliston Warriors (2004-present) managed by John Lisi
- also known as New Milford Warriors (2004-2009)
- also known as Melrose Warriors (2010-2013)
- Largemouth Trouts (2004-present) managed by Patrick Cavanaugh and Joe Gillespie
- also known as Yellow Stars (2009-2010, 2002-2017)
- also known as Boston Braves (2004-2008)
- also known as Wuxi Opium Eaters (2011)
Expansion Era (12 Teams)
- Westborough Wildcard (2007-present) managed by Leo Pare
- also known as South Shore Sluggers (2012-2013)
- also known as The Rockers (2007-2012)
- formerly Polar Bears (2005-2006) managed by Joe Nicastro
- Thunderlips (2005-2013) managed by Mike McGrane/Paul LaGreca (defunct)
Ownership
Change 2009
- The Metal Head Empire (2009-present) managed by Joey Vignault
- formerly Cellar Dwellers (2004-2008) managed by Gil Lao
- also known as I'm Back Boys! (2004)
- also known as Another Go-Around (2005-2006)
- also known as Batting Cage Power (2007)
Ownership
Change 2011
- Multiple Scorgasms (2011-present) managed by Charles Kriete
- formerly Silver Bullets (2004-2010) managed by Will Titus
- also known as Goin' Yard (2004-2009)
Ownership Change 2012
- Barnstormers (2012-present) managed by Mike Lewis (defunct)
- formerly Royal Rooters (2004-2011) managed by Matt Cavanaugh
Ownership
Change 2014
Ownership Change 2015
- Goin’ Yard (2004-2010, 2014-present) managed by Will Titus
- formerly Thunderlips (2005-2013) managed by Mike McGrane/Paul LaGreca
- One Man Gang (2014-2017) managed by Joe Rouse
- formerly Irish Labatt (2004-present) managed by Tom Geary
Ownership Change 2015
- Rockford Peaches (2014-2016) managed by Michael Chase
- formerly Barnstormers (2012-2014) managed by Mike Lewis
- formerly Royal Rooters (2004-2011) managed by Matt Cavanaugh
Ownership Change 2016
- Abusement Park (2016) managed by Robert Armstrong
- formerly Rockford Peaches (2015) managed by Michael Chase
- formerly Barnstormers (2012-2014) managed by Mike Lewis
- formerly Royal Rooters (2004-2011) managed by Matt Cavanaugh
Ownership Change 2017
- Douchies R Us (2017-present) managed by Pete Souris
- also known as New Gronk City (2017)
- formerly Chin Music (2004-2016) managed by Grant Casassa, et al.
- BF Dent All-Stars (2017-present) managed by Greg Titus
- formerly Abusement Park (2016) managed by Robert Armstrong
- formerly Rockford Peaches (2015) managed by Michael Chase
- formerly Barnstormers (2012-2014) managed by Mike Lewis
- formerly Royal Rooters (2004-2011) managed by Matt Cavanaugh
Ownership Change 2018
- Shoot To Thrill (2018-present) managed by Frank Borelli
- also known as We're Great On Paper (2018)
- formerly One Man Gang (2014-2017) managed by Joe Rouse
- formerly Irish Labatt (2004-present) managed by Tom Geary